What is the Healthiest Caffeine Source?
I'm about to tell you
But first, grab my cliff notes of the book, "How Not to Die!"
Chat GPT made this chart. If you are finding the chart hard to read, click here to view the full excel sheet.
Â
The best sources of caffeine contain theobromine
Theobromine is a naturally occurring compound, structurally similar to caffeine, but with distinct and powerful benefits that make it uniquely helpful for the mind and mood. Found primarily in cacao, yerba mate, guayusa, and yaupon, theobromine acts as a mild, longer-lasting stimulant — but unlike caffeine’s sharp spikes and crashes, theobromine’s effects are smoother, more stable, and more sustainable.
It works by gently stimulating the central nervous system while also relaxing the blood vessels (a process called vasodilation). This improved circulation means more oxygen and nutrients are delivered to your brain, leading to sharper mental focus, clearer thinking, and enhanced cognitive function.
At the same time, theobromine has been shown to promote the release of serotonin, a key neurotransmitter involved in regulating mood, promoting feelings of happiness, calm, and emotional stability. This makes it an ideal choice for those who want to boost their energy and focus without the anxiety, irritability, or jitteriness that often comes with high doses of caffeine.
Additionally, because theobromine has a much longer half-life in the body compared to caffeine, its effects are gentler and last longer, helping you stay energized and positive for extended periods without the harsh crashes.
In short, theobromine supports both the body and the mind: enhancing mental clarity, lifting the mood naturally, promoting emotional resilience, and delivering clean, steady energy you can rely on throughout your day.
Below are links to sources of caffeine on Amazon that contain theobromine so you can try it out!
 Guayusa
If I had to crown a "clean, focused, plant-powered energy champion"—it’s guayusa. It combines the best parts of green tea, cacao, and yerba mate… but with a smoother taste, steadier energy, and less crash.
Buy it on Amazon Here
Yerba Mate
This is my favorite brand of Yerba Mate. While Yerba Mate usually has a strong, herbal flavor, this one tastes like lemonade—so yummy! It’s also pretty potent, so I typically use just half a scoop. I like to drink it in the morning before my workout, and sometimes I’ll add a bit of ginger powder or even Amla powder for an extra boost of antioxidants. (this flavor of Amla powder makes it taste like raspberry lemonade)
Buy it on Amazon Here
 Yaupon Tea
Packed with antioxidants and anti-inflammatory compounds that help protect your body from oxidative stress. The only naturally caffeinated plant native to North America, Yaupon is sustainably grown and harvested — good for you and the planet. Enjoy a smooth, slightly earthy flavor that's delicious!
Buy it on Amazon Here
 Cacao (Crio Bru)
You will need a french press to use Crio Bru. Cacao is packed with antioxidants, magnesium, and other minerals that promote heart health, reduce inflammation, and even help manage stress. With its rich, chocolatey flavor, it feels like a cozy treat, but it’s actually fueling your body in a much healthier way than coffee or energy drinks. Cacao also has the most theobromine (but the least amount of caffeine) out of all these options.Â
Buy it on Amazon HereLATEST FROM THE BLOG
Check out my latest recipes!
Check out my Youtube Channel if you want to see videos of how to put these recipes together!
